It's hard to list all our favorite places to eat. Especially because we eat a lot, and it's exhausting to write them all out.
But here's our attempt.
K-Town & Grace Street Cafe (Hodduk) & Food Gallery 32
Although it's basically only a block long on 32nd Street between 5th and 6th Avenues, Ktown is crammed with Korean barbecue, karaoke, beauty shops, and FOOD. Can you get better Korean food elsewhere? Yes. But if you're near Herald Square, you should do yourself a favor and at least take the tiny detour over to this street to get Hodduk (the best fried to order gooey donut you'll ever have) at Grace Street, and to pop into the food court (Food Gallery 32) for a steamed bun. Bonus: Just about everything at the Food Court is under $12 *and* there's a ton of seating throughout it's 3 stories. Downside: You will want more than just one Hodduk once you try it. You will probably also burn your mouth on it's molten brown sugar/cinnamon/walnutty bits.
Eataly
Mario Batali's ginormous Italian food emporium. Always crowded, but sometimes worth it. There's a lot of small restaurants and counters to get Italian eats. Our go-tos include the Prime Rib panino at 'La Rosticceria' and the sopresatta panini at 'I Panini'. Don't forget to get a scoop of gelato on your way out!
Ramen Misoya
This place offers several super rich miso-based ramen soups. We love the pork chashu.
Boka
They have KFC. No, not that Colonel Sanders sh*t - we're talking Korean Fried Chicken. Double fried for ultimate juiciness and crispiness, with an addicting sticky garlic-soy glaze (be careful, the spicy flavor is SPICY). They also have a bunch of other small plates to share, and watermelon soju if you're feeling festive. This place is also just around the corner from Ramen Misoya, in case you need a Plan B (or second dinner).
Fuku
Part of David Chang's Momofuku empire, Fuku's only entree is a spiced fried chicken sandwich with optional asian slaw (which makes it the Koreano). You can't get a better chicken sandwich in NYC for just $8-$9 a pop. Just a heads up - there's limited seating, so don't expect to be able to sit down with a big group of people.
Shake Shack
The best smash burger, period. In-N-Out has nothing on the Shack Burger. So deceptively simple, but it just works. Get the Shack Burger (although their chicken sandwich is darn good, too), with their old school crinkle-cut fries, and a shake. There's multiple locations around the city, so find one, hop on line, and figure out where you're going to nap off your food coma while you wait.
Katz's Deli
Katz's Deli is controlled chaos at its best. Here's a video on how the ordering/ticketing system works. It's pretty simple once you're in! It can get suuuper busy on weekends and random times of the week/day/night, but if you're looking for a "New York Deli" this won't disappoint. Order a pastrami on rye with mustard and unless you're ravenous, you might want to split it with someone.
The Meatball Shop
Customize your meatball experience! Choose your type of ball, sauce, and what you want them on (slider roll, sandwich, pasta, polenta, etc). Super yummy, and there's several locations around the city!
Whitmans (NYC) and Burnside (Brooklyn)
This is where Laura goes to curb a Jucy Lucy craving. Both places spell it wrong, but we forgive them because their burgers are on point. (Bonus points go to Burnside for also offering fried cheese curds and shuffleboard).
Big Gay Ice Cream
Softserve at it's yummiest! Get the Salty Pimp, make your friend get the Bea Arthur, and then eat them both.
Sundaes and Cones
This is hands down, Laura's favorite ice cream in the city. And if you know Laura and her penchant for frozen dairy, that's really saying something. Her favorite is Lavender, although their cookies and cream is a close second. Their scoopers are always super friendly, so try a few flavors before committing to your favorite scoop (or two, or three).